Listen to this article
Stanford Medicine scientists have found that insulin resistance can lead to an increased risk of developing a major depressive disorder.
The findings of the study were published in the ‘American Journal of Psychiatry’.
“If you’re insulin-resistant, your risk of developing a major depressive disorder is double that of someone who’s not insulin-resistant, even if you’ve never experienced depression before,” said Natalie Rasgon, MD, PhD, professor of psychiatry and behavioural sciences.
Upward of 1 in 5 Americans experiences major depressive disorder sometime during their lives.
Some factors contributing to this deeply debilitating disease — childhood traumas, loss of a loved one or the stresses of the COVID-19 pandemic, for example — are things we can’t prevent.
But insulin resistance is preventable: It can be reduced or eliminated by diet, exercise and, if need be, drugs.
Rasgon shares senior authorship of the study with Brenda Penninx, MD, PhD, professor of psychiatric epidemiology at the University of Amsterdam Medical Center. The study’s lead author is Kathleen Watson, PhD, a postdoctoral scholar in Rasgon’s group.
Studies have confirmed that at least 1 in 3 of us is walking around with insulin resistance — often without knowing it.
The condition does not arise from a deficiency in the pancreas’s ability to secrete insulin into the bloodstream, as occurs in Type 1 diabetes, but because of the decreased ability of cells throughout the body to heed this hormone’s command.
Insulin’s job is to tell our cells it’s time for them to process the glucose that’s flooding our blood due to our dietary intake of it, its manufacture in our liver or both.
Every cell in the body uses glucose as fuel, and each of those cells has receptors on its surface that, on binding to insulin, signals the cell to ingest the precious energy source.
But an increasing proportion of the world’s population is insulin-resistant: For various reasons — including excessive caloric intake, lack of exercise, stress and not getting enough sleep — their insulin receptors fail to bind to insulin properly.
Once those levels stay above a certain threshold, the diagnosis is Type 2 diabetes, a treatable but incurable condition that can lead to cardiovascular and cerebrovascular disorders, neuropathy, kidney disease, limb amputations and other detrimental health outcomes.
Associations between insulin resistance and several mental disorders have already been established. For example, it’s been shown that about 40 per cent of patients suffering from mood disorders are insulin-resistant, Rasgon said.
But these assessments have been based on cross-sectional studies — snapshots of populations at a single point in time.
The question of whether one event was the cause or the result of the other — or whether both were results of some other causal factor — are best resolved by longitudinal studies, which typically track people over years or even decades and can determine which event came first.
As a part of a multi-institutional collaboration within a research network Rasgon established in 2015, the scientists obtained data from an ongoing longitudinal study monitoring more than 3,000 participants in scrupulous detail to learn about the causes and consequences of depression: the Netherlands Study of Depression and Anxiety.
Rasgon is the Stanford principal investigator, and Penninx is the overall principal investigator.
“The Dutch study, with its meticulous monitoring of a large subject population for nine years and still climbing, presented a great opportunity for us,” Watson said.
The Stanford team analysed data from 601 men and women who served as control subjects for the Netherlands study.
At the time of their enrollment, they’d never been troubled by depression or anxiety. Their average age was 41 years.
The team measured three proxies of insulin resistance: fasting blood glucose levels, waist circumference, and the ratio of circulating triglyceride levels to those of circulating high-density lipoprotein — or HDL, known as “good” cholesterol.
They probed the data to see if the subjects found to be insulin-resistant had a heightened nine-year risk of developing a major depressive disorder.
By all three measures, the answer was yes: They discovered that a moderate increase in insulin resistance, as measured by the triglyceride-to-HDL ratio, was linked to an 89 per cent increase in the rate of new cases of major depressive disorder.
Similarly, every 5-centimetre increase in abdominal fat was related to an 11 per cent higher rate of depression, and an increase in fasting plasma glucose of 18 milligrams per deciliter of blood was associated with a 37 per cent higher rate of depression.
“Some subjects were already insulin-resistant at the study’s start — there was no way to know when they’d first become insulin-resistant,” Watson said.
“We wanted to more carefully determine how soon the connection kicks in,” Watson added.
So, the researchers restricted the next phase of their analysis to the roughly 400 subjects who, in addition to never having experienced major depression, also showed no sign of insulin resistance at the study’s onset.
The researchers compared this group’s likelihood of developing a major depressive disorder in the next seven years with that of the participants who hadn’t yet become insulin-resistant at the two-year point.
While the number of participants was too small to establish statistical significance for waist circumference and the triglyceride-to-HDL ratio, the results for fasting glucose were not only statistically significant — meaning unlikely to have arisen by chance — but clinically meaningful — that is, important enough to worry about: Those developing prediabetes within the first two years of the study had 2.66 times the risk for major depression by the nine-year follow-up milepost, compared with those who had normal fasting-glucose test results at the two-year point.
The bottom line: Insulin resistance is a strong risk factor for serious problems, including not only Type 2 diabetes but depression.
“It’s time for providers to consider the metabolic status of those suffering from mood disorders and vice versa, by assessing mood in patients with metabolic diseases such as obesity and hypertension,” Rasgon said.
“To prevent depression, physicians should be checking their patients’ insulin sensitivity. These tests are readily available in labs around the world, and they’re not expensive. In the end, we can mitigate the development of lifelong debilitating diseases,” Rasgon concluded.